Connect with us

New York Yankees

Superstar Shakeup?

Jesse Spector

Published

on

Stanton and Judge
Giancarlo Stanton and Aaron Judge appear to be good candidates to swap lineup spots. (Photo by Nick Turchiaro-USA TODAY Sports)

Sean Saint Jacques and Gary Phillips are your hosts for this episode, coming out of the Yankees’ last off day – scheduled off day, anyway, which has to be said because of all the weather they’ve faced – until May 7.

Since Sean and Gary lead off talking about the possibility of Giancarlo Stanton being moved in the batting order – a possibility Aaron Boone talked about – I want to address something about that, beyond the very good point made on the show about Stanton also getting off to a slow start last year before going on to win the National League MVP award.

Last year, Stanton started 154 games for the Marlins. He batted second 110 times, cleanup 35 times, fifth seven times, and leadoff and third once apiece. In other words, exactly where he bats in the order is not something that is going to mess with his head. So far with the Yankees, Stanton has been in the No. 3 spot in the lineup for all 16 games. Is it really a big deal if he moves? No.

Meanwhile, Aaron Judge started 62 games last year in the No. 3 spot, 30 as the No. 5 hitter, 28 batting second, 12 in the No. 6 hole, nine times cleanup, six times hitting seventh, and four games down at No. 8. He, too, is perfectly capable of moving.

And that brings up a possibility for the Yankees: rather than moving Stanton down in the order, it might make sense to just flip Stanton and Judge, having Stanton hit second and Judge third. Lineup protection is generally an idea that’s debunked, but it can be something that exists in extreme situations where you want to make sure not to issue a walk before facing a world-class hitter and the result is better pitches to hit. Stanton may be more vulnerable to pitch-arounds than Judge, who led the American League in walks last year and is top of the circuit again this year. With Didi Gregorius or Gary Sanchez hitting behind Judge, it’s not like he would be easy to give a base to, either, but he has shown plenty of ability to take them when given.

If you believe in the idea of protection, then it does make sense to protect Stanton with Judge, rather than the other way around, with big hitters still behind Judge. We’ll see what the Yankees do as they try to get their big offseason acquisition going and straighten out their early struggles.

Jesse Spector is a national columnist for FanRag Sports, based in New York. The host of "Jesse Spector Is..." on Tampa Bay Lightning Power Play Radio, Jesse is the former national baseball writer and national hockey writer for Sporting News. Before that, he was the Rangers beat writer for the New York Daily News, and the writer of the Touching Base baseball blog. Jesse also has written for Newsday, Baseball America, ESPN SportsTicker, and The Associated Press.

Advertisement
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Podcast

The Yankees’ offseason begins with some shocking news

Stacey Gotsulias

Published

on

Noah K. Murray-USA TODAY Sports

In today’s episode of Locked on Yankees, Stacey discusses all of the news that emerged just before this weekend began, she tells a story about a playoff game from many years ago, and she brings you up to date on both League Championship Series.

Continue Reading

Podcast

The season’s over for the Yankees

Stacey Gotsulias

Published

on

Brad Penner-USA TODAY Sports

In today’s episode, Stacey voices her bitter disappointment in how the Yankees’ season ended and more.

Continue Reading

Podcast

The Yankees are blown out in Game 3 of the ALDS

Stacey Gotsulias

Published

on

Brad Penner-USA TODAY Sports

In today’s episode, Stacey discusses the first three games of the Division Series with the Red Sox with an emphasis on Monday night’s debacle in Yankee Stadium. She also previews do or die Game 4.

Continue Reading

Trending